Previous section Navigate within course Next section
Course Overview
 - Slide for this section

Session 1

What is the Internet?

Internet vs other information resources

Finding a 'knowledge hub'

Search engines

- How they work
 - Comparing engines
- Using Top Three sites

Search strategies

Offline Assignment 1

Session 2

Evaluating information
Researching companies
Researching markets
Researching countries
Researching news
Search software
Offline Assignment 2

Search Engines (continued)

An In-depth Look at Search Engines

How results are ranked

Different search engines rely on proprietary search technology. Not only is each search engine's index of the Web unique, but the methods they have for finding and ranking hits in response to a query, will also differ. So many factors are involved in the latter process that what results is a special recipe for success.

Below is a table which compares some features of the search engines, showing differences in the way each engine ranks the results, by boosting each factor described in the table.

Search Engine Meta-tags Reviewed status  Link popularity
Altavista No No Yes
Google No No Yes
Northern Light No No Yes

What does this mean for a searcher?

Taken together, the differences will results in different results scoring top ranking with different engines.  What a searcher needs to do is to recognise that just because one engine hasn't returned the desired result in the first page, another search engine might.

In practice, you can either metasearch using MetaCrawler, Profusion, Mamma, etc, OR you can hop from search engine to search engine with the same query. (Partnered search engines like HotBot and Lycos make this easy by setting up the appropriate link at the bottom of your results page).  Be persistent and flexible with your query!

What does a search engine 'see' on a Web page?

Again, the exact mixture of features that a search engine will 'see' differs from engine to engine.  These features include:

  • The full text of the page
  • Meta-tags (which can give a description of the contents as well as relevant keywords)
  • Alt-text tags (the text which describes an image)

If you are used to using online information databases, you may be used to expecting that information is tagged to describe the contents.  Although this is possible with Web pages, only around 30% of pages have meta-tags.

Exercise Number 5: Metasearch vs Searching With a Single Engine

Suggested time for exercise = 10min SHOW HINTS

Advantages of metasearch:
  • you can cast a wider net, not just ~30% of the Web
  • saves time, with no need to search at several sites

Disadvantages of metasearch:

  • search syntax is not always well translated across engines
  • it is hard to see how 'hits' from different engines have been ranked or eliminated

This exercise demonstrate when and how you should metasearch.
Profusion is one of the better metasearch engines.

Find a video message from Jan Leschly, ex-CEO of SmithKline Beecham, about the future of the company.

Try to find this using Profusion, then Altavista and Google